MarketSmiths

MarketSmiths is a marketing agency at 320 Roebling St Ste. 747 in Brooklyn (11211). It was founded in 2010, which makes it older than 67% of the SEO companies we track in the city. The team is listed at 11-50 people. Its profile covers SEO, Advertising, Marketing strategy.

Clients rate it 5.0 out of 5 across 47 Google reviews, more than the city median of 13; 100% of those reviews are five-star, against 98% across Brooklyn. When we searched “seo agency near me” from Brooklyn on 1 October 2026, it appeared at #43; that search was led by Think Work Media - Digital Marketing Agency with 4 reviews.

Where the score comes from

Those three parts give an Explorer Score of 72/100, which places MarketSmiths 10th of 37 SEO companies in Brooklyn. How the score works.

Reviews in detail

100% five-star and 0% one- or two-star, against 98% and 1% across Brooklyn. 47 reviews is more than 86% of local SEO companies have, and among the 28 with ten or more, its review-weighted rating beats 89%.

Google Maps check

We searched “seo agency near me” from Brooklyn on 1 October 2026. MarketSmiths came in at #43, ahead of 39% of the 31 SEO companies checked. The top spot went to Think Work Media - Digital Marketing Agency, which has 4 reviews. An SEO company that cannot rank itself for its own service in its own city has not shown it can rank you.

What the data says

Strengths:

• A 5.0 rating from 47 reviews, well above the city median of 13.
• 16 years in business, against a city median of 13.
• Active profiles on 4 social networks.
• Online booking on its website.
• An owner-managed Google Business Profile.
• Open seven days a week.

Check before you sign:

• Only #43 on Google Maps for “seo agency near me”.
• No contact page on its website.

Best for: SEO and Advertising.

Services, website and presence

Services listed

Marketing agency, Advertising agency, Internet marketing service, Marketing consultant (4; local median 3)

Website

marketsmiths.com — “MarketSmiths® Content Strategists - Copywriting for Humans®”

Built on

Wordpress, about 1 pages, HTTPS, domain 16.8 years old

Contact page / booking

No / Yes

Social profiles

X, Facebook, Linkedin, Instagram

Google Ads

Not seen

Google profile

Owner-managed, 6 photos, open 7 days a week

Contact email

Not confirmed

Questions to ask MarketSmiths

1. You do not appear on the first page of Google Maps for “seo agency near me”. How do you win clients, and what results can you show for them?
2. Where does your own business rank on Google Maps for "seo agency near me" in this city, and why?
3. Which three clients can I look up on Google right now to see the rankings you built?
4. What do you do in month one, and what will I see in my reports by month three?
5. Do you build links, and where from?
6. Who owns the content and the tracking accounts if we part ways?

Quick answers

Is MarketSmiths a good SEO company?

MarketSmiths is a solid option in Brooklyn. Its strongest signal is a 5.0 rating from 47 reviews, well above the city median of 13. Before signing, note only #43 on Google Maps for “seo agency near me”.

How many reviews does MarketSmiths have?

47 Google reviews at an average of 5.0. That is more than 86% of SEO companies in Brooklyn; the median has 13.

Where is MarketSmiths located?

320 Roebling St Ste. 747, Brooklyn, NY 11211.

What does MarketSmiths do?

Its Google profile lists Marketing agency, Advertising agency, Internet marketing service, Marketing consultant. We tag that as SEO, Advertising, Marketing strategy.

Sources: Google Business Profile, the business's website and our Maps check. Figures as of 17 October 2026. ← All 37 Brooklyn SEO companies, ranked