Marketing Mayor

Marketing Mayor is a marketing agency at 1560 Harlem Rd Ste 9 in Buffalo (14206). Its profile covers SEO, Web design, Advertising, Marketing strategy, Video, a wider menu than most local SEO companies list.

Clients rate it 5.0 out of 5 across 5 Google reviews, fewer than the city median of 18; 100% of those reviews are five-star, against 97% across Buffalo. When we searched “seo agency near me” from Buffalo on 1 October 2026, it appeared at #21; that search was led by Clickmen™ Digital Marketing Agency with 117 reviews.

Where the score comes from

Those three parts give an Explorer Score of 68/100, which places Marketing Mayor 25th of 27 SEO companies in Buffalo. How the score works.

Reviews in detail

100% five-star and 0% one- or two-star, against 97% and 1% across Buffalo. 5 reviews is more than 0% of local SEO companies have.

Google Maps check

We searched “seo agency near me” from Buffalo on 1 October 2026. Marketing Mayor came in at #21, ahead of 21% of the 24 SEO companies checked. The top spot went to Clickmen™ Digital Marketing Agency, which has 117 reviews. An SEO company that cannot rank itself for its own service in its own city has not shown it can rank you.

What the data says

Strengths:

• Online booking on its website.
• An owner-managed Google Business Profile.
• Open seven days a week.

Check before you sign:

• Only 5 Google reviews, so the rating rests on a small sample.
• Only #21 on Google Maps for “seo agency near me”.
• No contact page on its website.
• Lists 6 business categories, so ask what it specialises in.
• Does not publish a founding year.

Best for: SEO plus a new website.

Services, website and presence

Services listed

Marketing agency, Advertising agency, Aerial photographer, Internet marketing service, Video production service, Website designer (6; local median 4)

Website

marketingmayor.com — “Marketing Mayor | SEO Agency for Buffalo NY and Orlando FL”

Built on

Wordpress, about 1 pages, HTTPS, domain 13.8 years old

Contact page / booking

No / Yes

Social profiles

None found

Google Ads

Not seen

Google profile

Owner-managed, 13 photos, open 7 days a week

Contact email

Not confirmed

Questions to ask Marketing Mayor

1. You have few public reviews. Can you share three recent client references?
2. You do not appear on the first page of Google Maps for “seo agency near me”. How do you win clients, and what results can you show for them?
3. When was the business founded, and who owns it?
4. You list 6 service categories. Which two make up most of your work?
5. Where does your own business rank on Google Maps for "seo agency near me" in this city, and why?
6. Which three clients can I look up on Google right now to see the rankings you built?

Quick answers

Is Marketing Mayor a good SEO company?

Marketing Mayor is worth a look, with a couple of checks first. Its strongest signal is online booking on its website. Before signing, note only 5 Google reviews, so the rating rests on a small sample.

How many reviews does Marketing Mayor have?

5 Google reviews at an average of 5.0. That is more than 0% of SEO companies in Buffalo; the median has 18.

Where is Marketing Mayor located?

1560 Harlem Rd Ste 9, Buffalo, NY 14206.

What does Marketing Mayor do?

Its Google profile lists Marketing agency, Advertising agency, Aerial photographer, Internet marketing service, Video production service, Website designer. We tag that as SEO, Web design, Advertising, Marketing strategy, Video.

Sources: Google Business Profile, the business's website and our Maps check. Figures as of 17 October 2026. ← All 27 Buffalo SEO companies, ranked